OS 7.1–iPhone 5s

by cdwise 21. September 2013 10:47

A few days ago I updated my iPad 3 to iOS 7 and was taken aback at the new interface. Not only do I find it fugly but also less usable as well. Some of it is downright inaccessible. Despite which I picked up a new iPhone 5s yesterday when they first hit the streets. My impression of iOS 7.1 which is available for the iPhone 5 but not the iPad 3 is better that it suits the phone better but none of my real issues were addressed.

While I’m a fan of swipes and gestures some of the changes make absolutely no sense to me. I loved how easy it was to use my thumb to not only move between screens but also to pull up the search screen since I have both business and personal contacts on my phone as well as a lot of music and audio books. Simple swipe in from the left, start typing the name and choose from the list. Much quicker and easier than opening contacts and searching or scrolling through the long lists there. Now I have to pull down on the icons to get search with Notifications dropping down more often than the search bar appearing. I had to google to figure out how to search. I also had to google to find out how to close applications when I loaded iOS 7 on the iPad. You really shouldn’t have to use an internet search engine to find out how to do something on a phone you’ve been doing for years because of an OS change. This is particularly annoying since Apple could have added the swipe down for search without removing the traditional method.

iOS 7

First, I hate the default color scheme. While I’m not a fan of black interfaces in general the very light colors and poor contrast on the iPhone of the default white or almost white text on a light midtone gray is such a low contrast I can’t believe anyone from Apple ever heard of minimum contrast for accessibility under WCAG,  §508 and similar statutes most governments around the world require. First thing I did was change the background and I’m not changing it back just to get a screenshot. So let’s take a look at a few of the new iOS 7 apps.

The absence of color in the interface is something I do not like. Okay, in a few apps like Messages it doesn’t make any real difference. Text is crisp and sharp, it is easy to tell who sent which part of the message thread. The flattened mostly monochromatic interface reminds makes me feel like I’m back in 1991 in some cases, back in 1982 b&w monitor only in others. Instead of feeling “fresh” it simply feels “old”.

I didn’t like it when Microsoft went to the flat minimal color tiles for Windows 8 and like it even less on my Apple products. Sorry Apple but you really shouldn’t copy Microsoft when it comes to design. Design and UI are supposed to be Apple’s strength. You can’t tell it from this OS.

My other color related annoyance is the colors the OS chooses as the background behind persistent icons and app groups. I’ve seen a few screenshots where someone has chosen just the right background for those areas to be attractive. Sadly, I haven’t found one in the included options nor among the over 1,000 photos on my phone. I may have to try and make one in Photoshop that will be an attractive background AND give me an appropriate static background.

My last comment about the interface itself has to do with app groups. Love the fact that you can put more apps in a group so I don’t need multiple groups with names like Photography, Photography 1. Hate the limit of 9 icons showing when the group is launched and having to scroll in groups of 9. Even on the iPhone 4 and 4s there is plenty of room for a group of at least 12 like there is in iOS 6. On the taller iPhone 5, 5c and 5s you could put 16. On the iPad it just looks ridiculous. So call this one 1 step forward for function but 2 steps back for implementation.

Notes App

From the reaction I’ve seen when I mentioned Notes on facebook and to a few friends apparently most people don’t use it but I do because it syncs to Outlook and it is always available not matter if I’m on my phone, iPad, Windows, Mac or any other device that syncs with Outlook. The original Notes app uses a simple yellow legal pad as a metaphor and background.  Text is a crisp black, hyperlinks are a dark red with an underline . The icons at the bottom of each note. Below is the same note open in iOS 6 and iOS 7.

notes006 Some of the changes such as the background going from yellow to dingy white are no big deal. Though I prefer the yellow background, whitish will do.

What really bothers me is that the hyperlinks and icons are now yellow which makes them very difficult to read. – Note: the screenshot on the right is with Settings > General > Accessibility > Increase Contrast turned on!!!

Think how bad it would be if contrast had not been increased. The only way I have found of changing the background and foreground colors is to invert the colors so you have light text on a black background. That would be something I’d do if this were the only app I cared about. However what it did to my background pictures and to many of the icons was enough to give me a headache. Heck, if Apple had even stuck with the dark red for icons and hyperlinks in this application I wouldn’t be bitching about it.

iTunes App

Next, change for the sake of change that may end up being a much bigger issue for me is the change to iTunes. I listen to audio book all the time when traveling, exercising and yes, even when working. This means that sometimes I want to rewind a bit because I missed something. In iOS 6 backing up a 4 minutes or going back a chapter or two was easy. The current chapter playing has a nice wide bar for only that section of the book as you can see in the image below.

007003Chapter 12 is 17:30 long and it is easy to move the player within that short section.

If you want to go to a different chapter switch to the list view and all the chapters are laid out in a nice neat list. Simply select the Chapter you want to hear.

With iTunes in iOS 7 all that easy functionality is gone.

bookbook2Now instead of a per chapter play bar the entire length of the book is condensed to the width available. What was once 17:30 in Chapter 12 to move within is now 5:36:54 seconds. Try to move back 3 minutes with your finger when there is that much time is such a small space.

No more nice breakout by chapters in list view anymore either. Instead you have “songs” on an “album”. Which may work well for music albums where song length rarely exceeds 6 minutes it is a terrible interface for recorded book, lectures and other audio forms. There goes easy navigation.

Weather App

This is the last app I’m going to mention that has changes I could have done without. My son also mentioned it as one he was particularly unhappy about. 002weather

Nice large easy to read in iOS 6. A simple swipe down gives you hourly forecast when you want it.

The new version – white text on medium background. Sure the current temperture is easy to read but the forecast for the following days – not so easy. The raindrops in the original are  easy to see at a glance but barely discernable in iOS 7. Not to mention hollow outlines of clouds with spects to indicate rain require you to look closely to tell what they mean. The colors and contrast in the original app require no such close scrutiny.

Control Center

notificationThis is a much better implementation in many ways than the simple audio controls that would come up on a locked screen in iOS 6. The ability to access many common tasks without launching an app or going through multiple screens under Settings IS a significant improvement. However, the same low contrast issue I’ve had with iOS remain.

Kudos to Apple for putting the ability to turn off and on different types of connections, airplane mode, adjust audio, take a photo and turn on the flashlight quickly and easily.

I just wish there was a little more thought taken for accessibility. White text on a light midtone background. Tell me how easy it is for you to read the airdrop and phone setting options in the screenshot on the right?

In your quick settings – white means it is enabled and the darker gray means that it is disabled? That’s backwards from every convention I know of where you gray out what is not available.

iPhone 5s – Hardware

Now that I’ve summarized what I think of the software let me give you my impressions of the hardware.

First, the feel of the phone is fantastic. I never thought of my iPhone 4s as heavy but compared to the 5s it sure is. There is a significant and noticeable difference in weight that really surprised me.

The high resolution screen is crisp and sharp – the only thing that makes the flat bland low contrast colors of the new OS even remotely tolerable. If I could go back to the UI of iOS 6 I guarantee that I would.

Fingerprint reader – extremely accurate once you invest in the time it takes to enroll your fingers. That’s one of the reasons I went for the 5s not the 5 or 5c. The other was the speed of the processor. It flies in comparison to my older 4s.

Conclusion

I’m extremely pleased with the hardware and hope that Apple fixes the OS quickly. I’ve had my reservations about iOS 7 ever since I saw the first screen shots. Those reservations proved to be not only accurate but if anything the iOS 7 is worse than I expected from those screenshots and reviews. Change for the sake of change is usually a bad thing – this OS proves it.

Tags:

Accessibility | iphone

Comments are closed


Outstanding Hosting